New Report Suggests a Rapid Transition to Renewables Can Result in Huge Savings

A study examining the historic prices of fossil fuels and renewable technologies suggests coal, oil and gas might not actually be as cheap as common.

Author Mark Newton, 09.26.22

Translation Sarah-Indra Jungblut:

At RESET.org, we cover a wide range of technologies concerning power generation – all the way from familiar solar and wind to breakthroughs in fusion energy. When discussing renewable energy, one negative issue always seems to rear its ugly head: cost. Often renewable technologies are seen as less reliable and simultaneously more expensive than traditional fossil fuels, which are often defined as being ‘dirty but cheap’.

However, a new study emerging from Oxford University suggests this might not actually be the case. Their results suggest that while fossil fuels are certainly dirty, comparatively speaking, they are not that cheap.

Oxford’s Institute for New Economic Thinking examined historic price data for both renewable and fossil fuel energy to create a long term comparisons. In the case of the fossil fuel data, they went back to the peak of the industrial revolution in the 1880s. When plotted over the entire 140 year timespan and adjusted for inflation, the researchers concluded that fossil fuels, such as coal, oil and gas, are highly volatile and subject to significant increases and decreases with no overall long term trend. Importantly, however, the price of fossil fuels today are largely the same as they were in 1880, and in most cases are more expensive.

Meanwhile, the costs of renewable technologies are only getting cheaper. Although originally starting at a much higher price point, many renewable technologies are now cheaper than oil and approaching coal and gas. On average, renewable technologies, such as solar, wind and storage batteries, have dropped roughly ten percent per year since their commercial introduction and continue to decrease.

Additionally, although fossil fuels currently provide more energy production, the amount they produce has only increased slightly since 1880, and in many cases has plateaued. Renewables on the other hand, have only increased in efficiency and are now approaching the production levels of fossil fuels.

With this data, the team used probabilistic modelling to develop three future scenarios (Fast Transition, Slow Transition, and No Transition) regarding the shift from non-renewable to renewable sources, and assessed their likely costs from 2020 to 2070. Their analysis suggests that a rapid transition to renewables (by 2050) is significantly cheaper than both the Slow and No Transition model. They concluded that by 2050, the annual energy system cost for the Fast Transition model was 514 billion USD cheaper than the No Transition scenario. When taking into account changes in changes in interest rates and the additional cost fossil fuels would impose on other areas of society, the team concludes savings could ultimately be as high as 12 trillion USD.

The Fast Transition scenario is especially beneficial as increased investment into renewable technologies will only further improve the technology, likely reducing costs and increasing output.

Ultimately, the report and the Oxford team view with scepticism the suggestion that a shift to renewable power would lead to a drop in GDP and astronomical prices. Instead, the transition could result in massive savings in only a relatively short space of time.

A Windy Future: Can Wind Power Lead our Clean Energy Revolution?

Bob Dylan famously claimed "the answer is blowin' in the wind". Does the same apply for our growing energy and environmental crisis?

A Bright Future? How the Next Generation of Solar is Overcoming its Many Challenges

Solar power is one of the best-known sources of renewable energy, but it is still only responsible for 3 percent of global electricity. What's keeping it back and how can it further develop?

New Breakthroughs in Nuclear Fusion Announced – But How Clean is Fusion Power?

Fusion power is still some decades away, although new strides are being made every year. But how does fusion compare with nuclear fission power?

100 Percent Renewable Energy Needs Efficiency and Intelligence. Interview with Severin Beucker (Borderstep Institute)

How can we successfully transform our energy system towards climate neutrality? For Severin Beucker, co-founder of the Borderstep Institute, the most important prerequisites are efficient and intelligent grids and consumers.

Is Hydrogen Storage the Future of Renewable Energy?

There are many potential ways to store surplus renewable energy, but hydrogen is emerging as one of the most promising. New advances are making it cleaner and more practical.

Thermoelectric Breakthrough Wants to Turn Hot Industrial Pipes into Power Generators

Flexible and efficient thermoelectric generators could be molded to a wide range of different heat emitting industrial processes.

Virtual Power Plants and Peer-to-Peer Trading Can Take Small Producers to the Next Level

Digital technologies are providing even small mini-grid developers with the tools to act like the big guys.

Power to the People: How Can Civic Tech Help Create a Local Energy Revolution?

Civic technology helps communities put power into their own hands - quite literally. New open source technologies can provide powerful tools to those looking to set up local renewable energy grids.