“Electric Cars Play a Key Role in the Shift to Green Transportation”

© Andreas Labes
Michael Müller-Görnert from the VCD.

The future looks bright for e-mobility. But electric vehicles aren't the only alternative to traditional combustion engines. What are the other options? And how do they shape up? We talked it over with Michael Müller-Görnert from VCD, Germany's leading ecological transport association.

Author Lydia Skrabania:

Translation Lydia Skrabania, 03.21.17

When we talk about sustainable mobility, the conversation tends to revolve around electric vehicles. And e-mobility is currently experiencing a huge upsurge in interest and sales. But there are other alternatives to petrol and diesel vehicles, besides electric motors. How likely is it that they’ll catch on, and what are their potentials and possible pitfalls?

RESET talked to Michael Müller-Görnert about exactly that. He’s responsible for transport policy at the VCD, with a focus on air pollution control and climate protection, a member of the executive board of Transport & Environment (T&E) – the European umbrella organization of environment and transport associations – and also the leader of various projects in the field of propulsion systems and fleet management.

When it comes to alternative fuels and sustainable mobility, electric vehicles are at the forefront. What’s your view of the situation?

Germany has set itself the goal of having a million electric vehicles on the roads by 2020. But with currently only about 50,000 electrically powered cars, we’re miles away from reaching that goal. That’s why the German government set up a new support programm for electric vehicles last year. While some of the motives for the government’s target setting undeniably have to do with industry, promoting e-mobility is starting the necessary shift towards carbon-neutral transportation. One thing is clear: in order to reach national and international climate targets and the subsequent greenhouse gas neutrality by the middle of the 21st century in the field of transportation, essential forms of transportation must be powered using methods that are practically emissions-free. That’s where we need electric motors powered by renewable energies.

What sustainable alternatives exist outside electric and what is their potential?

As more ecological alternatives to petrol and diesel and in order to diversify the range of drives on offer, the German government has been promoting vehicles with natural gas and liquid gas engines with a lower fuel tax that will last until the end of 2018. That’s why gas is so much cheaper when you go to fill up. Particularly when compared to diesel, natural and liquid gas have distinct ecological advantages: the vehicles produce only very low levels of pollutant emissions (nitrogen oxides and particulates). That’s around the same level of pollutants as petrol. But they have better credentials than petrol when it comes to CO2 emissions. Natural gas vehicles emit 25 per cent less CO2, liquid gas 10-15 per cent. And natural gas vehicles can also run on regeneratively produced methane – biomethane created from the fermentation of residual and waste materials, or synthetic methane created from water using electrolysis. Depending on the pre-production processes, the CO2 advantage can rise to between 60 and 90 per cent.

Despite the fact they’re more environmentally-friendly and the fuels are cheaper, gas vehicles still remain a niche product. Germany has approximately 500,000 liquid gas cars and 100,000 natural gas cars in comparison to 45 million petrol and diesel vehicles. Current plans are for the tax break for natural gas to be carried on until 2026, as they are of greater benefit to the climate, and the tax break for liquid gas to end in 2018. In the opinion of the VCD, in climate protection terms it makes sense to continue the tax break for natural gas, but there should also be a limit on it. Because if we are to decarbonise then – as I already described – we require a rapid switchover to emissions-free drives. Given the limited potential of renewable natural gas, that alone can’t provide a solution.

What do you see as the future potentials for fuel cells and the like? What are possibilites and risks do they pose?

Due to the reasons I already mentioned, electric cars, whether they’re powered by batteries or fuel cells (Note: which use hydrogen gas – rather than electricity – to power an electric motor), play a key role in the shift to green transportation. All other drive technologies have too small a potential for reducing CO2 or there aren’t enough resources to provide the operating power that is needed. But electric vehicles need clean energy. That’s why a switch to clean energies is critical for the future of e-mobility. The most efficient method is the direct use of renewable energy in battery-powered vehicles or, like with trains, via overhead lines.

With fuel cells, almost half of the energy used is lost during the production of the hydrogen that is needed. But they have a bigger range than battery-powered electric vehicles. The technology is currently still expensive, however, and right now there areonly two fuel cell cars that are in mainstream production. We also have no fuelling infrastructure for hydrogen.

Electric vehicles don’t just have a larger range of models, they’ll also be getting more affordable in the future, and it’s expected that by 2025 they’ll be able to compete with conventional cars in terms of price. At the same time currently – not only in Germany – the charging infrastructure is being expanded massively. We have to look at the possibilities for hydrogen cells within that context. Risks for e-mobility are a continued lack of acceptance amongst consumers, low fuel prices, and the as-yet-still-unclear negative social and ecological affects of rare minerals (including lithium) for the production of the batteries.

The future looks bright for e-mobility. Want to find out which countries are leading the way, how electric vehicles are now holding their own against the rest of the market, and what innovative startups are doing to keep e-mobility moving forward? You can find all the articles here: RESET Special E-Mobility.

E-Mobility: Where Is It Taking Us?

Climate change, particulate pollution, C02 emissions: If we're to make a switch from fossil fuels to clean energy, the transport sector needs to find new concepts, alternative energy sources, and innovative solutions.

PlugSurfing: Why Driving an Electric Car Is Already Paying Off

Electromobility is catching on, but progress is slow - many potential new users are still put off by the charging process, and afraid of getting stuck in the middle of nowhere with an empty battery. The PlugSurfing app wants to simplify things: declaring war on the confusing jungle of charging stations, energy providers and billing systems.

Good Charging Infrastructure Could Put an End to Range Anxiety

Why has it taken so long for electric mobility to catch on? The main suspect: range anxiety, the fear of getting stranded with a flat battery. But with sufficient charging infrastructure and a rethink of the way we refuel, we could easily make it a thing of the past. There are enough good solutions available - we just have to put them into practice.

Join the E-Mobility Revolution

Using greener and more sustainable transport options is crucial if we're to meet climate targets and reduce air pollution in cities around the world. Fume-free, more sustainable and developing rapidly, electric vehicles could offer an effective alternative to traditional gas guzzlers.

How Green Is E-Mobility? It All Depends on the Power Source and Where the Battery Ends Up

Electric vehicles are currently touted as the most eco-friendly way to get from A to B. But what's the truth behind their supposedly green credentials? We've taken a closer look at their life cycle to see how they really shape up.

Wireless Wonder: The Electric Car Of The Future Will Charge Itself

Calling itself "the future of wireless power", Blue Inductive has made a bold statement. But maybe there's something in it. The German startup, based in Freiburg, has developed a technology that allows electric cars to be charged not just quickly but completely cable-free.